
Our Therapists
Experienced Mental Health Counselors
At Calla Lily Counseling LLC, we are committed to offering top-notch mental health counseling services. Our team is dedicated to supporting individuals, couples, and families as they navigate life's challenges and enhance their overall well-being.
We understand therapy can be challenging! Our therapists are here to guide you through the process, providing practical tools to help you thrive on your therapeutic journey.
We believe therapy should be personalized, not a one-size-fits-all solution. Our team takes pride in developing tailored strategies for clients, while fostering a positive environment for personal growth.
Why Choose Calla Lily Counseling LLC?
Our Therapy Can Help with


Motherhood
Experiencing unique challenges as a new mom? Our therapists can provide you with a safe space for healing and growth, helping you navigate your journey with care.
OCD
Navigating OCD can be difficult, but our therapists can help you learn effective techniques to help you manage symptoms that impact your daily life.
Self-Exploration
Embarking on a journey of self-discovery is empowering, and our therapists can guide you in exploring your thoughts, emotions, and personal growth.

Life Transitions
Transitions in life can be daunting, but our therapists can provide you with the support and guidance to navigate change and find a sense of direction.
Trauma Recovery
Recovering from trauma is a challenging process, but our therapists can help you heal and rebuild your sense of safety and resilience.
Addiction
Prioritizing your well-being is essential, and our therapists can support you in minimizing or eliminating substance use, while developing healthy habits and coping strategies for a balanced life.
Meet the Calla Lily Counseling Team!
Welcome to Calla Lily Counseling, where our team is dedicated to supporting your mental health journey. Our team of experienced counselors are committed to providing high-quality care tailored to your individual needs. We believe in fostering a safe and compassionate environment, along with helping you navigate life's challenges with understanding and expertise. Your well-being is our priority, we are here to guide you every step of the way.
.jpg)
Lindsay Tosh, LPC
Practice Owner
Lindsay is a seasoned professional with over 10 years of experience in the health care field, proudly serving as a Licensed Professional Counselor (LPC) in Pennsylvania. With her specialized EMDR training, she has excelled in a variety of settings, including psychiatric hospitals, youth residential facilities, drug and alcohol rehabilitation centers, and private practice. Her extensive background allows her to deliver tailored, impactful support, empowering clients to overcome challenges and achieve lasting healing. Lindsay is dedicated to guiding clients on their path to wellness with confidence and expertise.
Specializations:
EMDR Trained/Trauma
Postpartum issues
Neurodivergence - ADHD/Autism
Terminal/Chronic illness

Kassandra Luttmann, LPC
Kassandra is a dedicated drug and alcohol counselor with over four years of experience. She specializes in supporting adults facing mental health and substance challenges, creating a validating and encouraging environment for her clients. With a Master’s Degree in Clinical and Mental Health Counseling from Kutztown University, Kassandra employs a person-centered approach, incorporating Motivational Interviewing and Cognitive Behavior Therapy to help clients achieve their therapeutic goals. Expect a warm, collaborative experience that makes therapy approachable and less intimidating, often infused with humor to ease the journey.
Specializations:
Anxiety
Depression
ADHD
Mood disorders​

Sydney Fisher, LPC
Sydney earned her Master's Degree in Clinical Mental Health Counseling in May 2022. With over 5 years of experience, she has worked with adolescents, adults, and geriatric populations facing challenges such as substance abuse, dual diagnosis, and severe mental illness. Sydney employs person-centered approach, meaning she walks alongside her clients as they navigate their journey through counseling. Her compassionate demeanor provides a supportive environment for healing and growth.
Specializations:
Dual Diagnosis
Substance abuse
Severe mental illness

Maeve Smith, MA
Maeve is a mental health professional specializing in obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) and the unique needs of children through young adults. With experience in schools, community mental health, and intensive outpatient care, she has extensive training in exposure and response prevention (ERP) therapy for OCD, as well as expertise in grief, trauma, and crisis prevention. A graduate of the University of Pittsburgh’s Clinical Mental Health Counseling program, Maeve takes a collaborative approach, empowering clients to navigate change and growth with confidence.
Specializations:
OCD
Trauma
Grief

Melanie Nagy, Master Level Intern
Melanie is completing her graduate training at Grand Canyon University. She holds a bachelor’s degree in Criminal Justice from California University of Pennsylvania and a post-baccalaureate certificate in Forensic Science and Law from Duquesne University.
With over 18 years of experience in the correctional field, Melanie brings a deep understanding of resilience, stress, and trauma-informed care. Her work has shaped her passion for supporting first responders, law-enforcement professionals, and individuals navigating demanding or high-pressure environments.
Melanie’s therapeutic style is warm, holistic, and strength-focused. She integrates cognitive-behavioral and solution-focused strategies while honoring the connection between mind, body, and spirit. Her intention is to create a grounded, compassionate space where clients feel seen, supported, and empowered in their healing process
Specializations:
Anxiety & Depression
Stress & Burnout
First Responders & Law Enforcement
Insurance Options and Self-Pay Rates:
1
We Accept:
United Health Care / Optum
UPMC
Cigna
Aetna
Highmark
Blue Cross Blue Shield
IBX
2
Self-Pay Rates:
30 Minutes: $70
50 Minutes: $135
Therapy Intensives: $150 per 60 minutes
Take the First Step Towards Healing
Contact Information
Phone
Location
412-532-6639
Pittsburgh, PA